Deer Creek Island Resort
Kayak and paddleboard rental business with pontoons and jet skis.
Details
Google Reviews
Extremely Disappointing Experience — Unsafe Boat and Terrible Customer Service If I could leave negative stars I would. We rented a boat with a tube for 4 hours and paid well over $800. Unfortunately, after about 2 hours, we could barely steer the boat. Something was clearly wrong, and we felt extremely unsafe continuing to operate it. We called the emergency number on the boat and explained the situation to the employee who answered. She told us to bring the boat back in. When we asked if there was another boat we could use for the remaining 2 hours, she said no. We then asked for a refund for the unused portion of our rental, but she told us they don’t do refunds. When I pointed out that they had given us a boat that was not functioning properly, she said we could speak with the manager to see what could be done. We slowly made our way back to the docks, and it took approximately 30 minutes because we could barely steer the boat. The employee called us after about 15 minutes asking if we were bringing it back, even though we had already explained how difficult and unsafe it was to operate. When we returned, the two young employees loading the boat appeared to handle the process carelessly, scraping the bottom of the boat and leaving the propeller down. Their attitude was extremely casual, which was frustrating given the safety concerns we had just experienced. When we went back to the office, we were told again that there would be no refund. Their solution was to offer us 2 free hours on a future visit. My family was visiting from out of town, and this was a special opportunity for us to spend time together. We explained that we wouldn’t be coming back, but they were unwilling to offer a reasonable solution. After approximately 30 minutes of arguing, they told us we could take the boat back out because they had supposedly fixed it. That would have required us to reload all of our belongings, get towed back out, relaunch the boat, and travel back to the middle of the lake. By that point, we would have had perhaps an hour left, and we had no confidence that the boat wouldn’t break down again. The experience had already completely taken the fun out of our day. We eventually agreed to accept the 2-hour free rental because they were unwilling to work with us on a refund, despite the amount we had paid. We later discovered that the “free” 2-hour rental comes with additional conditions, including a minimum rental requirement, which made the offer feel even less useful. The most disappointing part was the way we were treated. We felt that the employees were dismissive, condescending, arrogant and completely uninterested in our safety or our experience as customers. We were treated as though our concerns were an inconvenience rather than a legitimate issue involving a malfunctioning boat. This was supposed to be a memorable day with family who had traveled from out of town and whom we rarely get to spend time with. Instead, the experience was stressful, frustrating, and ruined a significant part of our vacation. After this experience, I will not be returning to Deer Creek Reservoir for a boat rental, and I would not recommend this service to others. If you are considering renting from them, I strongly encourage you to read the other reviews and carefully consider whether this is the experience you want to risk having. Save your money and choose a rental company that prioritizes customer safety and treats people with respect.
The best experience! I rented a jet ski and from start to finish they were so kind, and walked me through everything! I was worried about having to pull it onto the trailer; whoever the amazing guy was talked me through it the whole time haha. Would highly highly recommend renting from here!
I DO NOT recommend renting boats from these people. Rentals are WAY overpriced, specially for the one we got, which was the open bow “sport” boat. The boat was in terrible condition. Rips in all the upholstery, chips, and scuffs on all of the fiber glass, which doesn’t make sense considering they charge 100 dollars per inch of damage to either material. You’d think it would be in great condition, but apparently they just take your money, and don’t bother repairing any of it. They also don’t tell you up front that fuel cost is not included in the rental fee. We ended up paying another 100 dollars for fuel at the end of the day. The guy that launched us initially had a terrible attitude. We payed 1200 dollars just to rent it for 6 hours. only to break down an hour into our day. We had to wait over an hour for anyone to get to us, and fix it after I had called, and told them exactly where we were. Mechanic said that a connector had broken near the terminal, which he didn’t even fix by the way. He just bent it back, and started the boat a few times, and said “you’re good to go” even though I saw BRAND NEW connectors in his tool bag. When asked for a refund, or a discount for the inconvenience their reply was “I don’t know”. They ended up giving us another hour for free, but it didn’t seem worth it. Long story short. Go through a third party, or a private renter if you want to rent a boat.
ATTENTION ANYONE who got a rain check! The rain check policy is so sneaky and selfish. They told my family we could get a 90 minute rain check to use on a different day. They did not tell us, nor can I find it anywhere on their website that in order to use your "rain check" you have to buy a minimum of a 2 hour rental and then it will be added on top of that. So for example we would have to get a 3.5 hour rental (2 hours paid plus 1.5 hour rain check). Yeah no thank you, I am not wanting to spend an additional 250 dollars just to use my rain check. This is after my family already spent hundreds of dollars on our original reservation. This is a ridiculous policy and I will not support this company again.
I love the reservoir, but this rental company was frustrating to work with. Nothing they did was illegal, but they were dishonest and clearly didn’t care about the customer experience. Don’t waste your money on the insurance. It still comes with a $500 deductible that wasn’t clearly disclosed and wasn’t anywhere in the paperwork we were given. You’ll still end up paying for almost any damage short of sinking the machine. Our wave runner developed an issue before our rental time was up, but instead of helping us or offering any refund for the lost time, they were uncooperative and wouldn’t even show us the documents we had signed. The hour we spent on the water was fun, but the way they handled problems left a bad taste in our mouths.
Location
Open in Google MapsIs this your business?
Claim it free to keep your hours, photos and details accurate. Claiming costs nothing and always will; featured placement is a separate, optional upgrade.

